Nottingham Lake, Colorado, USA

Also known as:  Benchmark Lake, Benchmark Lake Reservoir

Welcome to the ultimate guide to Nottingham Lake — things to do, where to stay, fun facts, history, stats and more. Let’s dive in!

Topics we cover in this article:

Looking for Nottingham Lake cabins or other accommodations? Save time and use this interactive map to find, compare and book at the best rates. Or explore our comprehensive list of favorite travel partners.

All About Nottingham Lake

Nottingham Lake sits at the heart of Avon, Colorado. A source of water, recreation and pride, Nottingham Lake is surrounded by the beauty of west central Colorado’s Rocky Mountains. Tucked in a valley along the Eagle River, Harry A. Nottingham Park and Nottingham Lake are found a short eight miles west of Vail and within view of scenic Beaver Creek.

What are now world-renown ski slopes were once called “the shining mountains” by people of the Ute Nation. Abundant wildlife and rushing rivers provided summer hunting grounds for the Ute. The same beaver, bear and deer attracted mountain men and trappers by the early 1800s, but the Eagle River Basin did not see its first Anglo settlers until the 1880s. William Nottingham arrived in the valley in 1882 where his son, Harry A. Nottingham was born. Harry became a prominent citizen who ranched and farmed half of his parents’ homestead until his death in 1966. Harry A. Nottingham Park and Nottingham Lake are named in his honor.

Nottingham Lake, also called Benchmark Lake, is an impoundment of Buck Creek, a tributary of the Eagle River. Built in 1980, Benchmark Dam now provides an emergency water supply to the city of Avon. The earthen dam, essentially a levee, rises along the south and west shore of Nottingham Lake helping to maintain an average depth of 10 feet and maximum depth of 15 feet. Sediment ponds located at the northeast end of the lake help to maintain water quality.

Today, Nottingham Lake and 48-acre Harry A. Nottingham Park provide a community space where residents can cheer on friends and neighbors at athletic fields, basketball courts, volleyball courts and tennis courts. The playground, picnic tables and cooking grills are excellent gathering spots for family and group cookouts. Plans have been discussed to extend hiking trails, but a single paved path already circles Nottingham Lake for walking, jogging, biking and in-line skating. During the summer, the sand beach makes a perfect space for sunning. Future long-range plans may expand water use, but generally swimming in Benchmark Lake is limited to special events. Swimmers will find a public pool at the multi-use recreation center built at the east end of the park. No motorized watercraft are permitted on Nottingham Lake but visitors may bring inner tubes, belly boats, canoes and kayaks to paddle across the 15-acre lake. For those who don’t own a boat or canoe, paddleboats are available for rent.

If you have a Colorado fishing license, Nottingham Lake has been stocked with trout and is available for fishing both summer and winter. With less than a mile of lake shoreline, anglers tend to gather along the south and west shores where the water is deepest. Don’t forget that the Eagle River lies immediately to the south of Benchmark Lake. Often less crowded than nearby Roaring Fork and Colorado Rivers, Eagle River is known for its wild rainbows, browns, cutthroats, and brookies. If you are looking for more secluded waterways, local outfitters are ready to take you to some of Colorado’s best mountain streams and lakes.

Outdoor adventures continue within surrounding White River National Forest. With names like Vail, Beaver Creek and Aspen found in White River National Forest, you know you are in the heart of bustling winter and summer resorts. For a slower pace, Eagle Ranger District maintains over 80 back-country trails open to hiking, horseback riding, mountain biking and in the winter, cross-country skiing and snowshoeing. The Glenwood Canyon Trail has a paved surface open to mountain bikes and in-line skating. A hut-to-hut trail system is available for an extended cross-country outing. Those desiring a true wilderness experience will find that White River National Forest is home to eight wilderness areas. Here, mountain peaks, alpine meadows, sparkling streams and blue skies combine for the ultimate Rocky Mountain experience.

In the midst of Colorado’s Northwest Tourism Region, spectacular scenery, and luxury resorts you will find the growing community of Avon. With an estimated population of 6,800, Avon is attracting an increasing number of seasonal residents. Half of Avon’s housing units are second homes. According to a 2008 community survey, 24% of these units are considered “long term rentals”, 27% “short term rentals”, 28% are for “owner use only”, and 45% are for “owner, friends and family use”. Drawn to the charm and hospitality of Avon, 22% of second homeowners have indicated that they plan to use their home as a permanent residence when they retire.

As a growing commercial center to Eagle County, Avon’s charming plazas are lined with shops, restaurants and services guaranteed to delight even the pickiest visitor. Truly the heart of this family-friendly community, Nottingham Lake is home to frequent family events including the Father’s Day fishing derby, 4th of July fireworks, Easter egg hunts, art festivals and the annual “Icing on the Lake” skate party. As a planned community, Avon has surrounded Nottingham Lake and Harry A. Nottingham Park with homes and condominiums that include readily available real estate properties and vacation rentals. Now is the time to find your property. Come to Avon’s Nottingham Lake and create treasured family moments on the shores of a sparkling lake surrounded by “the shining mountains.”

Things to Do at Nottingham Lake

  • Vacation Rentals
  • Fishing
  • Boating
  • Swimming
  • Beach
  • Canoeing
  • Kayaking
  • Tubing
  • Tennis
  • Picnicking
  • Hiking
  • Biking
  • Cross-Country Skiing
  • Horseback Riding
  • Hunting
  • Wildlife Viewing
  • Birding
  • National Forest
  • Playground

Fish Species Found at Nottingham Lake

  • Trout

Find Places to Stay at Nottingham Lake

If you’re considering a Nottingham Lake lake house rental or hotel, we’ve made it super easy to find the best rates and compare vacation accommodations at a glance. Save time using this interactive map below.

Recommended Sites to Book a Nottingham Lake Vacation

If you want to take a deeper dive to find waterfront lake cabins, cottages, condos, hotels or resorts, check out our favorite Nottingham Lake lodging partners.

  • VRBO – Use VRBO to find the perfect lake rental home, condo, cabin, cottage or other vacation property.
  • – One of the world’s leading digital travel companies, connects travelers to everything from cozy B&Bs to luxury resorts.
  • Expedia – Expedia is a popular online travel agency with more than 140,000 lodging properties worldwide.
  • – With more than 325,000 hotels in 19,000-plus locations, is an industry leader in online accommodations.
  • TripAdvisor – Read traveler reviews and compare prices on hotels, vacation rentals and more at TripAdvisor.
  • Trivago – Trivago helps travelers compare deals for hotels and other accommodations from a variety of booking sites.
  • KAYAK – KAYAK scours hundreds of other travel websites at once to find the best deals on hotels and other travel-related services.
  • RVshare –RVshare connects travelers interested in renting a motorhome with owners who have RVs to rent.
  • CampSpot – Campspot offers premier RV resorts, family campgrounds, cabins and glamping options across North America.

Note: These are affiliate links so we may earn a small commission if you book through them. While there is no extra cost to you, it helps provide resources to keep our site running (thank you)! You can read our full disclosure policy here.

Nottingham Lake Statistics & Helpful Links


Lake Type: Artificial Reservoir, Dammed

Water Level Control: City of Avon

Surface Area: 15 acres

Shoreline Length: 1 miles

Normal Elevation (Full Pond): 7,430 feet

Average Depth: 10 feet

Maximum Depth: 15 feet

Water Volume: 100 acre-feet

Completion Year: 1980

Lake Area-Population: 6,800

We strive to keep the information on LakeLubbers as accurate as possible. However, if you’ve found something in this article that needs updating, we’d certainly love to hear from you! Please fill out our Content Correction form.

Shop Nottingham Lake Gifts

Custom Lake Tumblers

Captain / First Mate Custom 20 oz Tumbler

Custom Lake T Shirt

Personalized My Boat My Rules Unisex T-Shirt

Custom Lake Coffee Mug - On Lake Time

On Lake Time Custom Coffee Mug – 11oz or 15oz


Advertise Your Nottingham Lake Business or Vacation Rental

LakeLubbers will soon offer businesses the opportunity to advertise and homeowners and property managers the ability to showcase their vacation rentals to the thousands of lake lovers searching our site daily. If you would like additional details, please contact our advertising team.


Looking for the Nottingham Lake Forum?

LakeLubbers previously offered visitors the ability to create accounts and participate in lake forums. When we overhauled the site’s content management system in 2021 we had to disable those features. We’re evaluating options and welcome your comments and feedback here. We also encourage you to join our lake-lovin’ community on Facebook, Instagram and Pinterest!

Nottingham Lake Photo Gallery

New photos coming soon!

Spread the word! Share our Nottingham Lake article with your fellow Lake Lubbers!